Skip to main content

I was trying to walk and document the entire Batangas coastline, as I've done in a dozen other countries, but in Laiya…

AxiomSyntaxStructureNov 13
Local TalkReddit122

I was trying to walk and document the entire Batangas coastline, as I've done in a dozen other countries, but in Laiya a private security guard stopped me from going any further and told me the sea is private property. Locals, can a coastline actually be owned and controlled? What does the Water Code say?!?

The Hugom Rock Formation was supposed to be the highlight and final destination of my Laiya trip, but La Luz Beach Resort blocked the way and I couldn't get to the end. They subtly pressured me, implying that if a report were filed, their word would be believed over some random passerby's, and said the law doesn't matter for what they do, so I avoided that kind of confrontation and gave up on the trip...

I thought this was a place with public access, as guaranteed by the constitutions of most countries, but I went through a laughable situation that resembles what's happening in the South China Sea. The guards stopped me and my family from following the coastline to our final destination. They couldn't cite a single barangay ordinance or related law, only hinted that it was their duty to stop anyone and that the law doesn't matter... After walking all day, it was really disappointing. It's not a military facility or a shipyard, just a resort, yet it blocked our long trek. How can a private company literally take public property and rights, and even enforce it with private security? It's not a privately owned island or a classified site...

I had already seen resorts break the law by not providing reasonable beach access, but I think patrolling the beach and blocking coastal access goes too far.

What the comments sayAI summary of comments

Many replies say that beaches are public land and can't be privatized, and that having a Foreshore Lease Agreement (FLA) doesn't make a beach private property. Some also explain that under the Water Code, at least 3 meters along the shoreline is a public easement of passage that can't be blocked. Others point out, though, that if the landowner has political connections, the law doesn't really hold up in practice.

From
Reactions9 of 23 original comments
Record and SharePower and Security GuardsShoreline Leasing and Public AccessResort Admission
Record and Share
k3ttch72

You should have recorded the security guard saying the law doesn't matter and posted it online. The area in front of the beach is public property, so anyone should be free to walk through it. I understand this is strictly enforced in places like Boracay. You can still post this story on other online platforms so people find out about it. They have Facebook and Instagram pages too, so you can just tag them in your post.

Power and Security Guards
madmanjumper54

It's actually illegal, but the problem is that if the landowner is connected to politicians, the law becomes useless. Those rotten bastards are really persistent.

Shoreline Leasing and Public Access
Buds05104

It depends on whether that establishment has a foreshore lease agreement with the government.

Resort Admission
Ill-Growth-33860

This resort has a rocky section on its beach, so it's very careful about its area. Even during our stay, people kept getting hurt trying to take photos. The injured people weren't resort guests, so I can understand why the business is stricter about it. They also usually don't allow swimming in the rocky section, and there are flags that literally say it's dangerous. I think it was high tide when the poster went. The rocky section near the resort would have been underwater, with just a few flags showing. If people just slip and hit their heads on those rocks, I only hope the injuries are minor.

3

Comments 0

Please log into write a comment.