Localpedia founder John Sherwin Felix's reaction to a passenger who complained about the inconvenience caused by a group of Badjao on the train
I acknowledge and respect the work he has done with Localpedia. And that's a separate matter from this.
But John Sherwin Felix's comment on the train passenger's story was so out of touch and so self-righteous that it was uncomfortable to read.
He saw the photos of Badjao taking up seats, children left to roll around on a floor people walk all over, and a fare-paying passenger who worked 10 hours and can't even sit down, and all he came away with was "We need to understand their maritime culture"?
Nobody rides the MRT to attend an anthropology lecture. Everyone rides it to get home safely, on time, without standing for an hour holding their groceries.
"Not everyone grows up with the privilege of learning unspoken social rules."
Susmaryosep. You don't need privilege to know that the train floor is dirty, dangerous, and not a playground. You don't need a degree to know that when the train is packed, you shouldn't take up three seats with your bags or let kids block the aisle.
You talk about their historical circumstances, but what about the historical and socioeconomic circumstances of a Filipino worker who pays taxes, follows the rules, waits in line, doesn't beg, and just wants one seat?
Why is that person's reality never part of your empathy calculation?
This is a classic case of privileged posturing. Posting on Facebook from an air-conditioned room, acting broad-minded, while the real commuters, like a nanay holding her baby, a lolo with arthritis, and students packed in like sardines, have to bear the consequences of your "understanding."
Understanding has to go both ways. If you want to live in the city, beg in the city, ride the city's trains, you have to follow the city's basic rules. Don't hog seats, don't let kids play on the floor, don't make other passengers' lives harder.
Helping the Sama Dilaut regain their IDs, education, and livelihood back in their home communities is a separate conversation. That doesn't mean pretending everything happening on the train is fine, or treating everyone who complains as ignorant.
Stop glorifying bad behavior and calling it culture.
That isn't social awareness. It's putting down ordinary Filipino commuters to show off how woke you are.
It's hard to feel sympathy when you get threatened with being spat on, stabbed with a barbecue skewer, or having rocks thrown at you, and cursed at on top of that.
Poor commuters. Poor Bajau. Poor Filipinos. Government: 🤷🏻♂️
Ugh. Why can't people understand that two things can be true at the same time. People should be more empathetic toward others' circumstances. True. The Bajau have a bad reputation because they keep creating the stereotype of being a nuisance and a public danger. Also true. Fuck, both can be true. Yes, their circumstances led to an unfortunate lifestyle, begging, and being a nuisance in public spaces. Yes, they lack privilege and have less access to education. That's still not a license to keep living as the Philippine version of gypsies. And it's not an excuse for you assholes to look down on and demean them either. Fuck, the nuance is gone.
I'm really conflicted about this. I understand the ordinary commuters' side, and it's natural to be annoyed, and I've met aggressive Bajau myself. That aggression comes from being constantly driven away (PINAPALAYAS), whether at sea or on land. I spent a week meeting them in Tawi-Tawi, and I saw how they live in the middle of the sea, empty stilt houses along the coast, and boats housing nearly 100 to 200 people. They get robbed by pirates, and they get taken advantage of because they're uneducated or don't know better. It's not only in Manila that they get driven out. In Tawi-Tawi or Zamboanga too, whenever they come ashore they're always chased away. On other islands or in neighboring countries, their stilt houses even get burned. So the aggression is survival mode, and for most of them, being in Manila isn't even their own choice. They're trafficking victims. Think of the poor people who receive 4Ps (poverty-assistance cash grants); these people are even poorer than that. They're nomadic, stateless, and have no birth records, so they don't even have recognition as Filipinos, let alone the most basic services. Zero. Local governments, whether here or in other countries with Bajau communities, don't help them either because they're stateless. They have to survive on their own. Edit: I've only seen aggressive Bajau beggars in Manila, not in the places I visited in Mindanao where they live.
Note that what's being called out in the screenshot is these people's behavior, not the fact that they're Bajau. (If it wasn't cropped out) No matter where you're from, if you behave like that on public transport, you'll get called out.


Comments 0
Please log into write a comment.