Skip to main content

Attention, PNB customers.

Mark BrackleyNov 12
Local TalkFacebook

Attention, PNB customers.

First, some background. My debit card expired not long ago, which is understandable. The problem is that I never got any kind of notice about it. Like probably a lot of you, I completely missed the expiry date, even though I'd entered it countless times online. Ugh!

Anyway, I went to my local branch to ask what the replacement procedure was. My first mistake was going the day after the All Souls' Day holiday. The waiting area was packed, every seat was taken, and lots of people were standing. Being an impatient foreigner, of course (I'm saying it up front to head off the negative comments!), I just left and came back a few days later when it was quiet. My branch (Silliman, Dumaguete) uses the system that's common here, where a guard hands you a number ticket (card) depending on what you need. First problem: the guard gave me a number way ahead of the last one issued. I mean, he gave me number 37, but the window I needed was calling numbers in the teens (I'm not 100% sure, but keep that in mind). I only figured it out after waiting over an hour, when I saw people who'd arrived after me being served. I confronted the guard, and he gave me number 20. But I knew the last number called was 26, and I told him so. Then another guard checked, and it was now 29. So he gave me number 30! Great system, right? So it must be my turn now, right? Nope. Another woman with a lower number had left the building to go have lunch or something, and she had priority. By this time my wife, who is Filipina, had joined me, and she was furious, saying this wasn't normal. She and another customer who was equally angry confronted the branch manager. The manager shrugged and said that was their policy.

Finally I got to sit down with a staff member, and I had to fill out all the same paperwork I'd filled out when I opened the account three years ago! Yes, all of it, even the signature specimen, just to get one new card. They said they needed this information to make sure nothing had changed because the terms and conditions were updated. But the process of cross-checking the information was clearly a sham. I was angry and rushing as I wrote, and I made mistakes, so I knew there was missing or incorrect information on the forms. After all that, miraculously, the new card appeared. I wonder how long it would have sat there if I hadn't gone in! Anyway, putting this absurd process aside, I left happy to have the card.

But the bigger problem is the app. If you're a PNB customer with an iPhone and haven't signed up for Apple Pay yet, you may have received an invitation inside the app to enroll. I wanted to make a few payments, so I decided to try this method. But, not for the first time, the PNB app failed with a vague error message telling me to contact them if I needed help. Well, it wasn't unexpected, and I had nothing to lose anyway. But then, surprisingly, I received an old-fashioned text message (SMS) from a UK bank called Lloyds Bank asking about a withdrawal. The time of this message matched the time the PNB app failed exactly, down to the minute. I don't have a Lloyds account. No money left my PNB account or any UK account, and I got no notification from PNB. So I raised the matter with the branch. Their first response was "Oh, it's fine, no money was taken," which completely missed the point that the app might have been hacked. I offered to give them the details so they could notify their IT team, and again they said there was no need! I told them I'd been in IT for over 40 years, many of them as head of IT at a large company, so I know these threats well. They still didn't see it as a problem. For the record, I have two phones, and one is used only for banking and secure transactions. It has NordVPN for end-to-end encryption and Norton to protect the phone. I know it's not 100% foolproof! But the root cause of this potential incident can't be my phone, because it started with that app.

So, to those of you struggling with PNB, the choice is yours, but I don't recommend setting up Apple Pay through the app. If you must, activate it the Apple way.

Reactions10 of 43 original comments
Responsibility for card expirationCard replacement experienceQueue-jumping trickApp/Leak FeedbackOther banks
Responsibility for card expiration
Don Smith2

Keeping track of your expiry date and card usage is your own responsibility.

Card replacement experience
John Prior1

My PNB card expired last month too.. PNB texted me weeks ago to come pick up the card.. and of course I had to fill out forms and sign two receipt logbooks, even though I've banked with them for 20 years.. I said 'It's been 20 years and you still don't know my name?' but there's no point saying it..

Queue-jumping trick
James McInerney1

We also replaced our PNB debit card two weeks ago. Ours wasn't expired, but we showed our ID, did a few verifications, and were out in 5 minutes. There was a line but we just skipped it. I think it's because we occasionally bring snacks for the staff, like during holidays or just once in a while. For the security guard too. The guard is the key. He remembers us and takes us straight to the person in charge.

App/Leak Feedback
Bob Quinn1

This post just gave me one more reason not to open a bank account in the Philippines. The timing of the Lloyd's text coinciding with the PNB app failure is a coincidence. Since you don't have a Lloyd's account, I think the chance that the two are connected is very low. FYI, I've also been in IT for over 40 years and worked on online financial systems for several years.

Other banks
Douglas Jarman1

I have RCBC, BPI, and BDO... and I recommend them in that order... RCBC is by far the easiest to deal with and the online app is great too..

7

Comments 0

Please log into write a comment.