Skip to main content

5 Social Security mistakes that cost Americans in the Philippines — early claiming, withholding, Medicare

Naked ExpatNov 13
VideosYouTube34

5 Social Security mistakes that cost Americans in the Philippines — early claiming, withholding, Medicare

In one line
Andrew, who has lived in the Philippines for over 15 years, walks through 5 ways American expats lose money on Social Security, plus countries where payments are blocked and totalization agreements. He says he is not a tax advisor and that decisions should be checked with a qualified US expat tax professional.

💡 Key takeaways

[1. Claiming too early]
• Full retirement age (100% benefit) is 67 for anyone born in 1960 or later; the earliest claiming age is 62.
• Claiming at 62 means a permanent cut of about 30%, and since each yearly cost-of-living adjustment applies to the smaller base, the gap keeps widening, he says.
• Waiting from 62 to 70 raises the monthly benefit by about 77%. His example: $1,400/month at 62 vs $2,480/month at 70.
• Break-even is about age 78 for 62 vs 67, and about 82–83 for 67 vs 70, he says.
• He thinks expats are especially prone to claiming at 62 because of early relocation costs, and suggests delaying even to 65 or 67 if health and savings allow.

[2. The withholding trap]
• If the IRS classifies you as a nonresident alien, SSA must withhold 30% on 85% of your benefit, an effective 25.5% every month ($510 on $2,000/month, $6,120 a year).
• US citizens are generally treated as US residents for tax even while living abroad, so most aren't subject to it. Some green card holders, people who renounced citizenship, and certain tax-treaty cases are, he says.
• Check your tax residency with a tax advisor before moving, and if it applies, see whether a tax treaty can reduce or remove the rate.

[3. Ignoring the eligibility questionnaire]
• SSA sends eligibility questionnaires to beneficiaries abroad, usually every 1–2 years (checking address, eligibility, changes in circumstances).
• If you don't respond, payments are suspended until verification is done, which can take much longer from abroad because of international mail delays.
• Keep your address with SSA current, report every move within the Philippines, and answer questionnaires right away.

[4. Medicare Part B]
• Standard Medicare doesn't cover care outside the US, including the Philippines.
• But if you stop Part B and later move back to the US, a late-enrollment penalty of 10% per 12-month period without coverage is added for life.
• His example: the 2026 standard premium is about $185/month; after 5 years without it, you'd pay about $277/month for life.
• He thinks keeping Part B is the better choice if you might ever return to the US.

[5. Social Security Fairness Act (January 2025)]
• Signed into law on January 5, 2025, it repealed the WEP and GPO provisions.
• People whose benefits were reduced because of a foreign pension or a pension from work not covered by US Social Security (teachers, public employees, etc.), and their spouses and survivors, may see higher benefits, and since it is retroactive to early 2024, some may get back payments.
• If this applies, contact SSA directly.

[Blocked countries and totalization agreements]
• Countries SSA can't send payments to: Cuba, North Korea, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan.
• Check with the payments-abroad screening tool on the SSA website before you move.
• The US has totalization agreements with 30+ countries (UK, Canada, Australia, Germany, Japan, most of Western Europe), but the Philippines, Thailand and most of Southeast Asia have none.
• So self-employed people in the Philippines may owe US self-employment tax on foreign earned income.

⏱ Chapters
00:00 The man who claimed at 62
02:01 Mistake 1 — claiming too early
05:05 Mistake 2 — the withholding trap
07:07 Mistake 3 — the eligibility questionnaire
09:08 Mistake 4 — Medicare Part B
11:09 Mistake 5 — the Social Security Fairness Act
13:10 Countries where payments stop
14:11 Totalization agreements and this week's to-do list

💬 What viewers said (46 comments)
• Many said they claimed at 62 because the system may run short in the 2030s and quality of life in your 60s matters more. One said 62-claim benefits easily cover living costs in the Philippines.
• The withholding section drew pushback: US citizens aren't affected, and green card holders who keep their card aren't subject to it just for leaving the US.
• Commenters argued over whether Medicare Part B is optional, and one shared that declining it required filing a form in person at an SSA office.
• Others added that a younger spouse or a child changes the math because of survivor and child benefits.

1.4K views · 10.4K subscribers · Uploaded Sep 3, 2026 · 17:47 (as of Nov 16)

Reactions15 of 46 original comments
Corrections & extra infoThose who claimed at 62Q&A
Corrections & extra info
RobertGoodson-g4b3

Don't wait, collect as soon as possible: there is serious talk of cutting payouts in 2032, you're far more active at 62 than at 67, and I'm not sure where the 30% withholding comes from — for US citizens no such tax applies, however long you live abroad.

Those who claimed at 62
MoralHazard-mhz5

I claimed at 62 this year. Waiting until 70 would trade 8 years of my 60s for 8 years of gains in my 80s, and life at 62–70 can't be matched by your 80s. I can easily cover all my costs in the Philippines and still leave over 25% of my payout untouched.

Q&A
Boot89871

I'm a Canadian green card holder, divorced from my American spouse and moved back to Canada. What are my tax responsibilities?

2

Comments 0

Please log into write a comment.