農地改革は失敗した。フィリピンはこれからどこへ向かうのか?
わが国で最も論争的で、歴史的な根が深い問題のひとつですよね。アシエンダ(hacienda)の地主たちと、農民に分け与えられた彼らの広大な土地の話です。
でも、農地改革が失敗したのは明らかだと思います。法律で認められた小さな土地を受け取った農民はさらに貧しくなり、農業生産量はさらに悪化し、農民は仲買人の餌食になって借金に苦しみ、などなど。
最近公表されたDOJ(司法省)の見解は、農地改革法はもう失効したと述べています。施行期間が過ぎたので、有効な農地改革法はもはやなく(農地の最大所有面積の上限もなく)、フィリピンにはそういうものはないというのです。
では、私たちはここからどこへ向かえばいいのでしょうか?
I'm a son and grandson of a farmer and I now work in tech but studied economics in college. Seeing first hand the deterioration of the agriculture industry growing up (we used to sell cavans of our own rice, now our harvests can't even last us a year of just consuming it), the only solution is to consolidate farmland via cooperatives where farmers become stockholders instead of indivual, exploitable, small businesspeople, because that's what anything beyond subsistence farming is. A business. Money in money out. They then do what they do best but with the benefit of economies of scale, collective bargaining, and maybe direct government subsidies. They produce what they can sell at a fair market price with them pocketing a bigger portion the final farm to market profits and any shortfalls in supply will be covered by imports. Who will benefit? Farmers, retailers, consumers. Who will lose out? Traders and importers. Guess who has the resources to stop this from happening and also are incentivized do so. That's my two cents.
As a former Army officer I always say, "while we have a duty to defend the country, I cannot blame a farmer for taking up arms and joining the communist armed struggle"
in an interview, former Maharlika CEO said agrarian reform failed in the Philippines is partly cultural as well. The land given to initial land owners will subsequently be subdivided among the descendants of the original land owner, so economies of scale is impossible. 1 hectare farms are already small compared to the collectivized lots of cooperatives in neighbouring countries, let alone children of farmers further subdividing it for their own.
This is strange but Vietnam are dominated by tiny 1 hectare farms (89% are family farms) and they are world-class exporters. Million ppl backed by ministry formed massive regional blocks and maintain negotiation power for cheaper input and high sales. They were told to knock down their dikes, fund and share storage, logistics, auto irrigation system and fertilizer drones. One of their top banks (Agribank) are ordered to grant cheap easy loans to farmers for high-yield seeds and fertilizers with ridiculously low interest. In 2024, realizing the small farms model have reached their peak, they reformed but sided with small farms and protected their land ownership, yet allowed big corporations to lease thousand hectares for 50 years providing more centralized directive, advanced tech and massive funding for the farms. They made both small farms work and made reform work. So where did Philippine go wrong?
コメント 0
コメントを書くには ログインが必要です。